Most practice owners have had the thought at least once: “What if we just stopped taking insurance?”
It usually shows up right after a denied claim, or a prior auth that took three phone calls.
Most of what owners hear about going cash comes from people who went cash and love it. So before you decide, here are the questions to answer first, using numbers from our report, Cash-Pay Medicine in the US, 2000–2026.
Why are clinicians leaving insurance?
Physicians handle about 40 prior authorizations a week, which takes 13 hours of physician and staff time. And by the AMA’s math, Medicare pay fell 33% from 2001 to 2025, once you count the rising cost of running a practice.
If those numbers made you wince, you’re in good company. They’re a big part of why clinicians look at cash models.
Is cash pay growing in your field?
It depends a lot on your field.
In some fields, patients already pay a big share, and it grew from 2015 to 2022:
- Chiropractors: 32.6% to 41.0%
- Non-physician mental health practitioners (therapists, counselors): 19.4% to 24.2%
- Optometrists: 41.0% to 44.8%
In mental health, a large share of psychotherapists and psychiatrists don’t take insurance. Cosmetic care and LASIK are largely cash, and IVF often is, and GLP-1 care increasingly is.
In these fields, patients already expect to pay cash for some things. Where cash is rare, you’d be building that habit from scratch.
Who would actually pay you?
In concierge and DPC, many cash-pay patients have insurance. They’re paying extra for access on top of their coverage.
You can see it in how these practices run. Most concierge practices still bill insurance for routine care. For most of them, cash is extra income on top of insurance, not a replacement for it.
So build any cash offer for insured people who want faster access.
Can you find enough patients on your own?
When you take insurance, payer directories send people your way. Leave insurance and you leave those directories, too. Every new patient has to find you some other way: search, referrals, word of mouth, your website.
In the DPC Alliance survey, two-thirds of DPC panels weren’t full yet. These are practices built around the cash model from day one.
Before going fully cash, look hard at where your new patients come from today. If most of them come through your insurance networks, that stream stops.
You’d also be competing with bigger players than you might expect. A 2025 Health Affairs study found that concierge and DPC practices owned by for-profit corporations grew from 152 to 1,027 between 2018 and 2023. By 2023, they were about a third of all such practices.
What are you signing up for if you leave Medicare?
Opting out of Medicare is a long commitment. An opt-out lasts two years and renews automatically. First-time opt-outs get a short window early on to reverse it. After that, you have to cancel in writing at least 30 days before the current two-year period ends, or it rolls into another two years.
While you’re opted out, you see Medicare patients under private contracts and can’t bill Medicare for their covered care. Talk to your billing team or a health care attorney before you file.
Is there a middle path?
Yes, and it’s where most of the growth is: add a cash layer next to your insured care.
That could be a membership, or a service line insurance doesn’t cover well. You get to test whether patients will pay without giving up the ones your networks already send you.
Your insured patients count here, too. More of them pay for routine visits themselves before they meet their deductible. We wrote about how to win those patients last week.
Key takeaways
- Cash is already a big share of revenue in chiropractic, therapy, optometry and mental health, and still rare in much of medicine.
- In concierge and DPC, many cash-pay patients are insured and paying for access.
- Leaving insurance means finding every patient yourself. A cash layer lets you test demand first.
The full report has the field-by-field breakdown and every source: Cash-Pay Medicine in the US, 2000–2026.
Thinking about a cash model? We’ll look at whether your website and booking can carry it, and give you a straight answer even if it’s “not yet.”