Services Results Pricing About FAQ Insights ArticlesResearchProvider SpotlightFree Resources Contact Free Digital Health Check

Your Deductible Patients Aren't Shopping. They're Skipping.

A patient with a $2,000 deductible pays for the first $2,000 of their care. Until they hit it, your new-patient visit and their follow-up come out of their own pocket.

On paper, that turns them into cash buyers. You’d think they’d compare prices, call around, pick the best deal.

Most don’t. In the best study we found, workers facing a big deductible cut back on care instead. Here’s what we found while building our report, Cash-Pay Medicine in the US, 2000–2026, and what practices can do about it.

How many of your patients have a big deductible?

More every year. In 2009, 7% of covered workers with single coverage had a deductible of $2,000 or more. By 2025, it was 34%.

At small employers, it’s higher. KFF found that 53% of covered workers at firms with 10 to 199 employees carry a deductible that size. Those are a lot of the patients a private practice sees.

Do high-deductible patients shop around?

Not much. The clearest evidence comes from a large employer that moved every worker onto a high-deductible plan. Spending dropped because people used less care, and two years in there was still no sign they’d learned to compare prices.

That fits the broader picture. KFF’s 2025 survey found about 37% of insured adults skipped or delayed care because of cost.

So the patient you lose is usually deciding whether the visit is worth an unknown bill.

Doesn’t posting prices fix that?

It helps, but less than you’d hope. When researchers looked at a marketwide price tool, few people used it, and employer studies point the same way.

What seems to matter is a specific number at the moment someone is deciding. That’s usually a conversation, a text or an email.

What are practices doing about it?

In an October 2025 MGMA poll, about two-thirds of medical groups said patient-balance collections were flat or better, and 29% said they’d gotten worse. The improvers most often credited tighter front-end processes, like estimates and collecting at the visit instead of billing later.

Here’s what that looks like day to day:

  1. Give your front desk real numbers. When a patient asks “how much will this be?”, the answer should be a dollar figure or a range, not “it depends on your insurance.”
  2. Send an estimate before scheduled visits. A short text or email with the expected cost takes away the guesswork.
  3. Post your self-pay rates anyway. They won’t fill your schedule alone, but they answer the question for patients who look.
  4. Be reachable when patients decide. A cost question that reaches voicemail at 7 PM can turn into a visit that never gets booked.

What if an insured patient wants to pay cash?

Some will, especially if your self-pay rate is lower than what their plan would charge before the deductible. Two things to check first.

Under the No Surprises Act, a patient who chooses not to use their insurance counts as self-pay, so you may owe them a Good Faith Estimate before scheduled care. And some payer contracts limit how you can bill a covered patient. Your billing team or counsel can tell you where you stand.

If you run direct primary care, there’s one more option. Starting in 2026, patients with HSA-eligible insurance can pay DPC membership fees from their health savings account, up to $150 a month for one person or $300 for a family.

Key takeaways

  • About one in three covered workers now has a $2,000+ deductible, and over half at small employers.
  • In the best study we found, high-deductible patients cut back on care rather than shop for a better price.
  • A specific number before the visit, plus easy access, is the lever practices control.

The full report has the charts and every source: Cash-Pay Medicine in the US, 2000–2026.

Want to know how your practice looks to a patient trying to figure out what a visit will cost? We’ll check and tell you what we’d fix first.

Get Your Free Practice Score

We'll audit your website speed, local rankings, Google Business Profile, and missed call rate — completely free. No pitch, no pressure. Just your numbers.

✓ HIPAA Aware
✓ No Contracts
✓ Accounts in Your Name
✓ Healthcare Exclusive